A Rochester Fish Fry Done Right
Fish fry is a Rochester tradition, and it is the most ordered item on our menu. Every Elmwood Inn fish fry starts with a 12 oz fillet of fresh haddock and comes with our signature French fries, house-made coleslaw, house-made tartar sauce and a lemon wedge.
Beer Battered
The classic pub fish fry: light, crisp, golden batter around flaky haddock.
Breaded
A crunchy breaded coating for those who like a traditional fried haddock dinner.
Broiled
The same fresh haddock, broiled instead of fried, for a lighter plate.
Not that hungry? Ask for the petite fish fry, the same haddock in a smaller portion. We also serve a breaded haddock sandwich on a brioche roll.
What Rochester Says About Our Fish Fry
"Our fish fry dinners were delicious. The meals were huge. The fish was so fresh and the beer batter was crispy and not greasy. We will definitely be going back very soon!"
— Judith M · May 2023"Fish Fry is amazing. Julie the bartender is also fantastic!"
— Reid Lesswing · August 2024"My husband & I enjoyed a huge, delicious fish fry at Elmwood Inn today. Our waitress, Jennifer, was very friendly and we were waited on & served promptly. We will definitely be back soon!!!"
— Sheila Korn · March 2024"My buddy and I came out for their Friday Fish Fry and it was great! One of the very best we've had in a long time..."
— Luther Leong · September 2023"My wife ordered the beer battered fish fry. Probably the best batter ive ever had."
— Steve Passarell · June 2023"Tonight my husband and I each ordered the Beer battered haddock fish fry. The fish was fresh, the batter was perfect and the fries were excellent!"
— Nancy Chatterton · August 2022"Went the Elmwood for my birthday. I had the best fish fry I have ever eaten and the service was great!"
— lorigD2004KK · May 2022"We picked up two fish fries last night 1/29 and they were absolutely delicious! We think that they are the best in town."
— Beverly Voos · January 2021"One of my favorite places to go. Hands down, the Elmwood Inn has the best fish fry in town. Sooo good."
— Jane Smith · February 2020Fish Fry Questions
Do you serve fish fry every day or only on Friday?
Every day. Friday fish fry is the Rochester tradition, but you can order ours at lunch or dinner seven days a week.
What kind of fish do you use?
Fresh haddock, a 12 oz portion, prepared beer battered, breaded or broiled.
Can I get fish fry for takeout or delivery?
Yes. Order online at elmwoodinn.net or call (585) 271-5195 for takeout. We deliver in Rochester and nearby areas including Brighton, Henrietta, the South Wedge, Highland Park and the University of Rochester.
Is it busy during Lent?
Fridays in Lent are our busiest fish fry days. Ordering ahead online or by phone is the fastest way to get yours.
Where is the Elmwood Inn?
1256 Mt Hope Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, close to the University of Rochester, Strong Memorial Hospital and Highland Park.
Visit Elmwood Inn
Elmwood Inn
1256 Mt Hope Ave
Rochester, NY 14620
(585) 271-5195
| Monday – Thursday | 11 AM – 3 PM 5 PM – 9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM – 10 PM |
| Saturday | 12 PM – 10 PM |
| Sunday | 12 PM – 9 PM |